Used Vinyl Records in Milwaukee | We Buy Records

Milwaukee has always been a city full of collectors, DJs, and curious diggers — and at We Buy Records, we’re proud to keep that spirit alive. Whether you’re hunting for used records in Milwaukee or looking to sell your vinyl collection, our Riverwest shop is open every day from 12–4 PM and packed with second-hand treasures.

Buy Used Records from Real Collectors

We specialize in carefully sourced used vinyl LPs and 45s — everything from rock, jazz, soul, funk, disco, and R&B to punk, hip-hop, and metal. All records are cleaned, graded, and priced fairly by collectors who know the music. You can also find select titles available at our Cedarburg Fermentorium location, where we stock fresh used vinyl every week.

Sell Your Used Vinyl in Milwaukee

We pay top cash for clean used vinyl — LPs, 45s, 12-inch singles, and even select CDs, cassettes, and working audio gear. Bring your collection by the shop, or if you’re further south along the Racine–Kenosha corridor, we make regular house calls in that area. Selling your records locally means no shipping hassles, no online listing fees, and fast, honest offers.

Whether you’re downsizing, trading up, or just cleaning shelves, We Buy Records makes it simple — real collectors, fair cash offers, and zero pressure.

Frequently Asked Questions About Used Vinyl Records

Do you buy all genres of used records?

Yes — rock, jazz, funk, disco, punk, rap, metal, R&B, and more. As long as they’re in good condition, we’ll take a look.

Can I sell used records if I live outside Milwaukee?

Absolutely. We regularly travel across Southeast Wisconsin, including the Racine–Kenosha corridor, for larger collections.

Do you also sell used records at your shop?

Yes! Our Riverwest shop at 904 E Center St carries used vinyl daily, and our Cedarburg location is stocked weekly.

What condition should my records be in to sell?

Clean, playable, and complete albums (with sleeves) always bring the best offers — scratches, mold, or water damage lower value.

Explore More About Used Vinyl in Milwaukee

Learn how to buy, sell, and collect used records across Southeast Wisconsin — from Riverwest to the Racine–Kenosha corridor.

🎵 Used Records — Our main hub for everything used vinyl: buying, selling, and collecting in Milwaukee.
💿 Used Records in Milwaukee — Details on local buying hours, Cedarburg outlet, and regional house calls.
💰 Sell Used Vinyl Records — Step-by-step guide to selling clean LPs, 45s, and 12-inch singles directly to real collectors.