How Can I Sell Old Records?

There are a few different ways to sell them including online, rummage sales or to a local vinyl shop. We strongly feel that most people make more money with less effort by selling to a local shop like We Buy Records. No lifting, shipping, or complex computer skills needed!

How Much Are Old Records Worth?

All records have different values based on title and condition. The more a title is in demand, the harder it is to get and the better condition it's in the more valuable it can be. And vise versa, common records with little demand in poor condition will have little or no value. See the next question for more specifics!

Which Types of Records Are Valuable?

While there are exceptions to every rule, most of the valuable records these days are rock, r&b, jazz, punk, rap, or very obscure genres. Most classical, country, Christmas, opera and kids records have little or no value.

What Is The Process For Selling Records?

We recommend calling, texting or emailing with a brief description of how many records you have approximately and what styles of music. After we know this we can make recommendations for how to most easily get you a cash offer!

Should I Clean My Records First?

No! Unless you are a record expert do not attempt to clean them first! You may ruin them!

Who buys vinyl records near me in Milwaukee?

We Buy Records Milwaukee specializes in buying record collections locally with same-day quotes and immediate payment. House calls are available across Milwaukee, Waukesha County, Ozaukee County, and surrounding Southeast Wisconsin.

Where can I sell records near me?

We offer same-day quotes and fast pickup across Milwaukee, Wauwatosa, Shorewood, Whitefish Bay, Bay View, Racine, and Kenosha. More than 80% of sellers choose a house call instead of dealing with online listings or shipping.

What is the process for selling records locally?

Text or email photos of a few records or the spine of a shelf. Get a same-day quote based on real collector demand. Drop off locally or schedule a house call for larger collections. Get paid immediately - cash or digital payment.

Sell Records, Albums, and CDs in Milwaukee for Cash

We Buy Records Milwaukee is a local record buyer paying cash for vinyl records, album collections, and select CDs — with same-day quotes, house calls available, and no shipping or online hassle.

If you’re searching for sell records near me, who buys vinyl records near me, or where to sell records or albums for cash, we buy LPs, 45s, and complete collections across Milwaukee and Southeast Wisconsin.

📞 Call (414) 232-7606 💬 Text (414) 232-7606 ✉️ Email Andy

4.8★ Google rating · A+ BBB · Trusted Milwaukee record buyers

⭐ Read Seller Reviews

Who Buys Records and Albums Near Me in Milwaukee?

We Buy Records Milwaukee is Milwaukee’s established local buyer purchasing vinyl records, albums, and full collections with same-day quotes and immediate payment. Many sellers find us after searching for record buyers near me or where to sell records for cash and want a fast, in-person way to sell a collection — without shipping or online listings.

How Selling Records Locally in Milwaukee Works

📸 Text or email photos of a few records (or shelf spines)
💬 Get a same-day quote based on real collector demand
🚗 Drop off locally or schedule a house call
💵 Get paid immediately — cash or digital payment

This is why sellers searching for sell records near me or best place to sell vinyl records choose a local buyer instead of online marketplaces.

📞 Call (414) 232-7606 💬 Text (414) 232-7606

What We Buy in Milwaukee

We specialize in buying vinyl records, albums, and full record collections throughout Milwaukee. Clean, well-kept records and complete collections always receive the strongest offers.

We regularly buy classic rock albums, jazz pressings, 80s/90s indie, Northern soul & funk 45s, punk & metal albums, hip-hop, and private-press collections.

We also purchase select CD collections locally in Milwaukee, especially box sets, imports, jazz, classical, and large private collections.

Selling CDs as part of a larger collection? Learn how we buy CDs for cash in Milwaukee .

Selling Records Locally vs Selling Online

Many sellers start by considering Discogs, eBay, or Facebook Marketplace. For most people, selling locally is faster, safer, and ultimately more profitable.

Selling Locally (We Buy Records)

✔ Same-day quotes & immediate payment
✔ No fees, no returns, no disputes
✔ No grading arguments or pressing research
✔ House calls for large collections
✔ Trusted local buyers & real reviews

Selling Online (Discogs, eBay, Facebook)

• Time-consuming listings & photo work
• Fees, shipping costs, and platform cuts
• Returns, disputes, and condition complaints
• Risk of scams or damaged shipments
• Weeks or months to sell full collections

That’s why most sellers searching for sell records near me or best place to sell vinyl records choose a local buyer they can trust.

Where We Buy Records — Southeast Wisconsin Coverage

We buy vinyl record collections throughout Milwaukee and surrounding Southeast Wisconsin communities. Most sellers choose a local house call, but smaller collections are always welcome at our Milwaukee shop.

If you searched for who buys records near me or where to sell vinyl records locally, we likely already work in your area. We make regular buying trips across the region and offer same-day quotes whenever possible.

We regularly buy record collections in:

Racine• Kenosha• Wauwatosa• Shorewood• Mequon• West Bend• Grafton• Cedarburg• Bay View

Visit Our Milwaukee Record Buying Shop

Open daily 12–4 PM
904 E Center St, Milwaukee, WI 53212

Trying to Sell Punk or Metal Records? We love buying these genres and pay top dollar!

How To Sell A Vinyl Record Collection

Reviews from People Who Sold Record Collections

“Wonderful experience! I sold a high price and rare 45rpm single to them, through the mail. Skeptical at first considering the value of the vinyl I was selling, but Andy made the experience very comforting and was quick to respond. Will do business again!”

— Ryan and Autumn Gentry

(note from Andy *** This was actually a $1500 garage rock 45 that Autumn’s uncle had recorded in the late 60s in Cincinnati, Ohio!)

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐

"It was great doing business with Andy. I am in Oregon and easily conducted the sale of a Rotel receiver and CD changer through email. Our transaction was quick and payment was very prompt. I highly recommend We Buy Records."
— Howard Saxion

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐

"Very easy transaction, Andy was more than fair and communication was great, would do business again!"
— James Dowd

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐

"Staff is very knowledgeable very helpful and understanding. Very very helpful as well thank you so much for being kind. They took a large problem off my hand. Thank you again you’re a blessing. Thank you."
— Cheryl Porter

We Buy Records spotlight by 88.9 Radio Milwaukee

88.9 Radio Milwaukee

Read Article

Text Andy To Sell Albums now

Explore More Ways to Sell Vinyl Records in Milwaukee

These helpful pages guide you through selling LPs, 45s, albums, collections and more across Southeast Wisconsin.

Who Buys Vinyl Records in Milwaukee? — see what we’re looking for right now.
How Much Are My Records Worth? — simple value guide for LPs & 45s.
Most Valuable Wisconsin Vinyl Records — local gems, private-press finds & Milwaukee rarities.
We Buy 45 RPM Records in Milwaukee — soul, funk, R&B, garage, modern soul & more.
Sell Vintage Stereo Equipment in Milwaukee — local only, no shipping needed.
Wisconsin Record Buyers — Full SE Wisconsin Coverage — see everywhere we make house calls.

Common Searches Milwaukee Record Sellers Make

People who contact us often start by searching things like:

who buys vinyl records near me sell records near me places that buy records near me sell old albums for cash sell vinyl records in Milwaukee vinyl record buyers near me

We buy 12” DJ singles! Click here to read about the most expensive 12” singles in the world!

📞 Call Andy to Sell Records