Sell Vinyl Records in Bayside, WI – We Buy Records Milwaukee

Live in Bayside and wondering where to sell your vinyl records? You’re in luck — Andy, the owner of We Buy Records Milwaukee, is a Bayside resident himself. That means if you’re in Bayside, we make house calls for any amount of records — big or small — since it’s so close and convenient. Whether you have a few boxes of LPs in the basement or a large collection of 45s, you can get fast, fair cash offers right here in Bayside.

See Tons of 5-Star Google Reviews from Actual Milwaukee-area Record Sellers Here!

📞 Call Now to Sell Your Records in Bayside
💬 Text Andy in Bayside

Illustration of Andy Noble, owner of We Buy Records

Why Sell Your Records in Bayside?

  • Local & Convenient: Andy lives in Bayside, so scheduling a visit is quick and hassle-free.

  • Any Size Collection: Because it’s so close, Andy is happy to stop by even for smaller record lots.

  • Cash Paid on the Spot: No shipping, no waiting, no online scams — you’ll get a fair cash offer right away.

  • Trusted Buyer: With an A+ BBB rating and hundreds of 5-star reviews, We Buy Records is Milwaukee’s most trusted record buyer.

What We’re Looking For


We buy all kinds of vinyl records in Bayside, including:

(No 78s, Broadway, Holiday, or damaged records please.)

House Calls in Bayside


Since Andy is a Bayside resident, you don’t need to worry about collection size or scheduling conflicts. He can come by quickly and evaluate your collection at your home.

FAQ – Selling Records in Bayside, WI

Do you really make house calls in Bayside?
Yes! Since Andy lives right here in Bayside, he’s happy to make house calls for any size record collection, even if it’s just a box or two.

What kinds of records do you buy in Bayside?
We buy LPs and 45s in genres like Rock, Jazz, Soul, Funk, Punk, Rap, Metal, and more. We also purchase select CDs, cassettes, and stereo gear.

Do you pay cash for records in Bayside?
Yes. We offer cash on the spot for your records. No waiting, no shipping, and no online hassle.

How quickly can you come out?
Because Bayside is so close, Andy can usually set up a house call the same day or within 24 hours.

What if my collection is small?
No problem! Unlike other areas where we need a minimum size, in Bayside Andy is glad to stop by for any number of records, big or small.

How do I get started?
Call or text Andy directly at 414-232-7606, or email andynoble1975@yahoo.com.