Sell Punk & Metal Records in Milwaukee — Trusted Buyers for Scene Veterans
We pay top cash for punk, hardcore, thrash, death metal, black metal, and rare underground LPs & 45s. Same-day replies, easy drop-off in Riverwest, or house calls across Milwaukee & SE Wisconsin.
Whether you shopped at Mainstream Metal Shop, grew up at Milwaukee Metal Fest, or were part of the local punk & metal scenes — we understand these collections, their value, and their cultural importance. Sellers trust us because we’re collectors too.
If your collection includes OG pressings, local band releases, or private-press punk & metal, we're the most experienced buyer in the Midwest.
Why Punk & Metal Sellers Choose Us
Milwaukee has always had a serious punk and metal lineage. We buy collections from people who:
- Shopped at Mainstream Metal Shop back in the day
- Went to Milwaukee Metal Fest or played local shows
- Were part of the Riverwest, Bay View, and East Side punk scenes
- Collected DIY 7-inches, local label titles, or self-released demos
- Followed legendary Wisconsin bands like Die Kreuzen, Impaler, Morbid Saint, etc.
These aren’t generic record collections — they’re personal archives of shops, shows, friends, and Milwaukee music culture. We’re buyers who actually understand that, and it’s why people trust us when it’s time to sell.
What’s the best way to sell punk or metal records in Milwaukee?
The fastest way is to text photos to (414) 232-7606 for a same-day quote.
Do punk and metal records hold value?
Yes — OG pressings, DIY 7-inches, imports, and private-press titles are often highly collectible.
Do you make house calls for large punk or metal collections?
Yes — we travel anywhere in Milwaukee and SE Wisconsin for big collections.
Punk & Metal Records We Buy
We specialize in buying:
- 70s–80s punk & hardcore (Black Flag, Misfits, Dead Kennedys, Minor Threat)
- Thrash, death, black & speed metal (Slayer, Bathory, Death, Celtic Frost)
- Local and regional bands from Wisconsin & the Midwest
- DIY 7-inches, private-press LPs, and limited-run releases
- Imports, test pressings, color vinyl, promo-only editions
- Metal Fest-era bands and Milwaukee scene recordings
Clean collections get the highest offers. If you’re unsure, just text photos — we reply fast.
Selling Outside Milwaukee?
We buy punk & metal collections across SE Wisconsin:
FAQ — Selling Punk & Metal Vinyl
Do you buy CDs or tapes?
Yes — we buy select metal and punk CDs, box sets, imports, and rare cassettes.
How fast can you respond?
Most messages receive a reply the same day.
Will you travel for a large collection?
Yes, for qualifying punk and metal collections anywhere in SE Wisconsin.
How do I get the best offer?
Text clear photos of the spines or front covers to (414) 232-7606.
Ready to Sell Your Punk or Metal Collection?
We make it fast and easy. Same-day responses • Cash offers • Trusted by Milwaukee collectors, musicians & longtime scene members.
📞 Call (414) 232-7606 💬 Text Photos ✉️ Contact Us