What Is The Process For Selling Records?

We recommend calling, texting or emailing with a brief description of how many records you have approximately and what styles of music. After we know this we can make recommendations for how to most easily get you a cash offer!

Should I Clean My Records First?

No! Unless you are a record expert do not attempt to clean them first! You may ruin them!

Sell Records Near Me – We Buy Vinyl in Milwaukee & SE Wisconsin

Looking for who buys records near you? We Buy Records Milwaukee pays cash for vinyl LPs, 45s, and full record collections — fast, fair, and local.

📞 Call to Sell Records 💬 Text to Sell Records Sell My Record Collection

⭐ 4.8★ Google Rating · A+ BBB Accredited · Read seller reviews

Who Buys Records Near You?

Andy and the We Buy Records team buy vinyl record collections for cash every day across Milwaukee and Southeast Wisconsin. We’re a local record store known for fast, straightforward offers and same-day payment.

If you’re looking for where to sell records or who buys old vinyl near you, this is the simplest way to get it done.

What We Buy

Vinyl LPs and 45s in collectible genres including soul, rock, jazz, funk, disco, punk, metal, indie, hip-hop, gospel, and related styles. Large collections welcome — house calls available.

Sell My Record Collection

Or call or text Andy at 414-232-7606

Areas we cover!

CEDARBURG - RACINE - KENOSHA - BROWN DEER - GREENFIELD - BAY VIEW - WEST ALLIS - MILWAUKEE - SHEBOYGAN - PORT WASHINGTON - WAUWATOSA - NEW BERLIN - BROOKFIELD - MEQUON - WAUKESHA - FRANKLIN - THIENSVILLE - LAKE GENEVA - MADISON - GREEN BAY - ALL OF WISCONSIN!

Outside Wisconsin? Rare Records Welcome

While most of our sellers are in Milwaukee and the Midwest, we do occasionally purchase rare and high-value records from outside the region.

If you have an individual record worth $500+ — such as scarce garage/psych 45s, top-tier jazz LPs, or other highly collectible titles — we’re interested.

Contact Us About a Rare Record

Still have questions? These are the most common things sellers ask before contacting us.

Frequently Asked Questions

How can I sell old records?

Just give us a call, text, or fill out our online form. We’ll review your collection and make an offer quickly. For local sellers in Milwaukee, we can often meet the same day.

Can I get cash right away when selling records?

Yes. We pay immediately—cash, Venmo, or Zelle—so you don’t have to wait. Most sellers walk away with cash the same day.

Where can I sell records near me in Milwaukee?

You can bring them directly to our Milwaukee shop on Center Street, or we can arrange pickup. We specialize in local collections and make the process simple.

How much are old records worth?

Value depends on rarity, condition, and demand. Many common titles are worth a few dollars, while rare 45s and LPs can be worth hundreds or more.

Which types of records are valuable?

We are especially interested in original pressings of jazz, soul, funk, punk, classic rock, and rare local releases. Don’t worry if you’re unsure—we’ll evaluate everything.

Do you buy 45s without sleeves?

Yes. Sleeves help but are not required. Many of the most valuable 45s we buy come without original covers.

Do you buy small or out-of-state collections?

We buy both. For out-of-state sellers, we usually consider high-value or specialized collections. Contact us for details and shipping options.

Should I clean my records before selling?

No—please don’t. Improper cleaning can damage records. We handle all professional cleaning and preparation ourselves.

We Buy Records spotlight by 88.9 Radio Milwaukee

88.9 Radio Milwaukee

Read Article

Get us some basic information about your records and we’ll get back to you with a plan same-day guaranteed!