Sell Vinyl Records in Milwaukee — And All of SE Wisconsin
House calls available for large collections across Milwaukee, Racine, Kenosha, Waukesha, Ozaukee & nearby areas. For smaller collections (300 records or less), you can bring them to our Milwaukee shop 7 days a week from 12–4 PM.
📞 Call (414) 232-7606 💬 Text Photos ✉️ Email Us
⭐ 4.8-Star Google Rating — Real Seller Reviews
“We’re in CA and Andy with We Buy Records sent us a shipping label… Once he verified the records were in good condition he immediately paid us. Exceeded all expectations.” — Linda
“Wonderful experience! I sold a rare 45rpm single through the mail… Andy made the experience very comforting and was quick to respond.” — Ryan & Autumn Gentry
“It was great doing business with Andy… Communication was great and I would do business again!” — James Dowd
Read More Reviews →What We Buy
LPs & 45s: Classic rock, jazz, soul, funk, blues, punk, metal, indie.
CDs & Tapes: Clean CD & tape collections
Stereo Equipment: McIntosh, Marantz, Sansui, Technics, JBL & more
We Buy Records Across the Entire Milwaukee Area
Milwaukee • Waukesha • Ozaukee • Washington Counties
Plus anywhere nearby for qualifying collections.
Popular Nearby Areas We Serve:
Shorewood • Wauwatosa • Brookfield • Mequon • Cedarburg • Grafton • Racine • Kenosha
House calls available for large collections only.
How Selling Works
1. Text us a few photos of your LPs, 45s, CDs, tapes, or stereo gear.
2. Get a same-day cash offer — often within minutes.
3. Choose pickup or drop-off at 904 E. Center St (12–4 PM daily).
FAQ
Do you make house calls?
Yes — anywhere in Milwaukee, Waukesha, Ozaukee & Washington Counties.
What do you buy?
LPs, 45s, CD/tape collections, and vintage stereo equipment.
How fast do you respond?
Most messages receive a reply within minutes.
Do you buy modern reissues?
Yes — clean modern LPs are welcome.
How do you pay?
Cash or instant digital payment on the spot.
Ready for a Fast Cash Offer?